| Season | Games Won | Games Lost |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | 4 | 2 |
| 3 | 10 | 6 |
| 4 | 6 | 10 |
| 5 | 3 | 3 |
| Player | Hand | BT | PT | PB | Pos 1 | Pos 2 | Pos 3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B.a. Dickey | L | S | NH | S | P | ||
| Brian Taylor | L | SM | TD | H | P | ||
| Chris Orosz | R | WC | EG | B | P | ||
| Thomas Beowulf | L | WC | BS | S | P | ||
| Dick Pole | R | MH | C | 1B | |||
| Xavier Quinn Jr. | R | BP | C | 3B | |||
| Dallas Houston | R | BP | 1B | 3B | |||
| William Lloyd Garrison | R | XB | 1B | 3B | |||
| Petetholomew Preller | L | 1B | EG | B | 1B | LF | |
| Sammy Tee | R | S | NT | H | 2B | SS | |
| Lincoln Lincoln | R | WC | 2B | RF | CF | ||
| Johnnie Twofingers | R | 1B | TT | H | 3B | 2B | |
| Nick Papagiorgio | R | EN | 3B | SS | |||
| Shogun Of Harlem | R | WC | 3B | LF | C | ||
| Michael Williams | R | S | SS | 2B | |||
| cocloctopus ikenmouseman | L | BN | EG | S | SS | CF | |
| Brian Talapia | L | BP | CF | RF | |||
| Babraham Thincoln | L | BP | RF | 1B |